Of course I agree with the #1 choice...ha ha!
I think I'd put knitty.com above Twist Collective though. Twist Collective, while beautiful and gorgeous, gives off an elitist air to me.
Not a "We're better than you!" elitism, but a "You've gotta be a pretty experienced knitter to knit any of the stuff in our magazine!" vibe.
Maybe "elite" isn't the right word. Not as accessible?
But the same goes for print magazines.
Obviously your Knit Simple isn't going to be on the same wavelength as say Vogue Knitting or Interweave Knits. So maybe I'm comparing apples to oranges in giving my opinion there.
I do know that's why I enjoy Knitcircus and knitty. They have a nice blend of multi-level projects.
And of course the baked goods in Knitcircus are just the best..ha ha!
What do you think? How would you rank your favorite online knitting magazines?